While some consider this a limitation of observational research, epidemiological models of causation e. This paper is a basic introduction to the process of metaanalysis. While studies using sr methodology were being actively published, some of these studies with the same research hypotheses began to yield conflicting results. In our metaanalysis, although based on a small subgroup of studies, the inclusion of those epidemiological studies that were restricted to clinically confirmed adhd cases e. David williamson, phd drummond rennie, md david moher, msc betsy j. Randomeffects models were used to pool association estimates. Various metaepidemiological studies have investigated the effect of blinding on estimated intervention effects. In this report the method of metaanalysis was used to summarize the results from these papers quantitatively. Association between htlv1 infection and adverse health outcomes. The statistical methods used to assess heterogeneity and publication bias are addressed in the section 1b chapter comparison of survival rates, heterogeneity, funnel plots, the role of bayes.
Metaanalysis of observational studies in epidemiology. Dsm diagnostic criteria led to a reduction of the pooledprevalence from 6. Welding fumes are classified by the international agency for research on cancer as carcinogenic to humans group 1, based on sufficient evidence of lung cancer from epidemiological studies. Metaanalysis is a method to obtain a weighted average of results from various studies. This approach has been used in several multicentre epidemiological studies. Bisphenol a bpa is suspected to be associated with several chronic metabolic diseases. The metaanalysis of all studies yielded a pooled or, adjusted for age and sex, of 1. A meta analysis of epidemiological studies susanna c. Background an estimated 110 million workers are exposed to welding fumes worldwide. Exposure to pesticides and risk of childhood cancer. May 05, 2017 these include ecological, caseseries, case control, cohort and interventional studies. Relationshipbetweencigarettesmokingandriskofchronicmyeloid. This paper is a basic introduction to the process of meta analysis.
Advancing maternal age is associated with increasing risk. After evaluating homogeneity among studies using the cochran q test, the authors calculated a pooled metaor stratified on each. Thus, statistical techniques for combining data from several studies with similar hypotheses is becoming. Ten studies were included in this metaanalysis, in which one was a cohort and nine were casecontrol. No metaanalysis study has been done on the association. Aug 28, 2015 the findings of epidemiologic studies on the association between fiber intake and prostate cancer risk remain conflicting. We aimed to examine this association by conducting a meta analysis of epidemiological studies. Method using recommended guidelines for performing metaanalyses, we systematically selected, and extracted results from, epidemiological scientific studies reported before january 2012. Thacker, md, msc for the metaanalysis of observational studies in. Thacker, md, msc for the meta analysis of observational studies in. Recently, it has also become popular among the interdisciplinary land change science lcs research community 7. The historical roots of metaanalysis can be traced back to 17th century studies of astronomy, while a paper published in 1904 by the statistician karl pearson in the british medical journal which collated data from several studies of typhoid inoculation is seen as the first time a metaanalytic approach was used to aggregate the outcomes of multiple clinical studies. Metaanalysis of prevalence journal of epidemiology.
Medline, embase, and psychinfo were searched for original. Pubmed and embase databases were searched up to august 2014 by two independent investigators using. Teb was asked to provide an evaluation of the epidemiological summary and meta analysis performed by zhang et al 2019 and to update the prior meta analysis done for our epa december 2017 revised glyphosate issue paper. Association between soy isoflavone intake and breast. Method fortyfour studies have reported the incidence of injuries in football. There were no significant differences for patients undergoing minimally invasive surgery, but patients with obesity who had open surgery had experienced higher blood loss and longer operative times not clinically meaningful as well as higher complication and reoperation rates. A meta analysis of 32 studies 23,415 patients was conducted. This meta analysis was performed according to the checklist of the meta analysis of observational studies in epidemiology moose guidelines. Observational and interventional studies often provide the best available evidence, however individual studies may lack power to provide either definitive or hypothesisgenerating knowledge. We discuss the logit and double arcsine transformations to stabilise the variance. Objective to conduct a metaanalysis of casecontrol and cohort. For a study to be excessively influential, the point estimate of the meta analysis result, done with the omission of the study, should lie outside the 95% ci of the combined meta analysis estimate, done with the inclusion of all studies. After evaluating homogeneity among studies using the cochran q test, the authors calculated a.
Metaanalysis of observational studies in epidemiology a proposal for reporting donna f. Objective to conduct a meta analysis of casecontrol and cohort studies on welding or exposure to welding fumes and risk. The relation between cigarette smoking and risk of acute. We conducted a metaanalysis of epidemiological studies investigating the association between maternal age and autism. Epidemiologic study types have their roots in the concepts of scientific experimenta tion. We further evaluated potential doseresponse relationship. The use of metaanalysis as a systematic approach to synthesizing data is a wellestablished analytic approach. The phrasing, content, and combinations of the chronic pain definition criteria were highly inconsistent, with virtually no 2 studies from independent research groups using the exact same criteria. Background shortterm exposure to outdoor fine particulate matter particles with a median aerodynamic diameter method we used is. A metaanalysis is a statistical technique used to combine the results of studies addressing the same question into a onenumber summary. Like large epidemiologic studies, metaanalysis run the risk of appearing to give. Various meta epidemiological studies have investigated the effect of blinding on estimated intervention effects.
In this article we present methods for the metaanalysis of prevalence. Teb was asked to provide an evaluation of the epidemiological summary and metaanalysis performed by zhang et al 2019 and to update the prior metaanalysis done for our epa december 2017 revised glyphosate issue paper. Uncritical adoption of techniques used in pooled analyses of clinical trial results may be inappropriate. Metaanalysis of observational epidemiological studies. This systematic method is recommended for practitioners evaluating epidemiological studies in the literature to arrive at an overall quantitative estimate of the impact of a treatment. We discuss the logit and double arcsine transformations to stabilise. Of 6791 hits, 86 studies were included in the syntheses. Larsson, nicola orsini and alicja wolk division of nutritional epidemiology, the national institute of environmental medicine, karolinska institutet, stockholm, sweden it has been proposed, on the basis of animal models and ecological studies, that consumption or metabolism of dairy sugar may. Our meta analysis of longitudinal studies has only become possible in the past few years because several such studies have been published that have used similar exposure indices namely, the. The association between exposure to general anesthesia and dementia risk has been inconsistently reported across epidemiological studies. Out of a total of 2053 records identified by the search 41 studies 43 publications were included in the meta. Messina m 2004 western soy intake is too low to produce health effects. Milkdairy products consumption, galactose metabolism and. Apr 25, 2018 few studies have been conducted in other regions, and metaanalysis has reported a prevalence of 14.
Methods two cohort and 38 casecontrol studies were selected for the first metaanalysis. Milk, milk products and lactose intake and ovarian cancer. Objective an uptodate metaanalysis of experimental research on talking and driving is needed to provide a comprehensive, empirical, and credible basis for po. This method represents a generic inversevariance approach to metaanalysis that incorporates an assumption that different studies are estimating different, yet related, intervention effects. Metaanalysis of observational studies in epidemiology moose group. Twenty studies were casecontrol studies and the other two were cohort studies. Indeed the direct comparison of results from metaanalyses. Bisphenol a and the risk of cardiometabolic disorders. Meta analysis of observational studies is as common as meta analysis of controlled trials confounding and selection bias often distort the findings from observational studies there is a danger that meta analyses of observational data produce very precise but equally spurious results. The studies included in this meta analysis were required to meet all the following criteria. Examples of the application of such techniques to the results of observational epidemiological studies are now proliferating. In addition to pooling effect sizes, metaanalysis can also be used to estimate disease frequencies, such as incidence and prevalence. Alcohol consumption and risk of myelodysplastic syndromes.
Therefore, in our study, we focused on longitudinal studies, which provide more robust epidemiological evidence than crosssectional, prevalence studies. Metaanalyses integration of findings by quantitative analyses of results of individual studies are already widely used in the psychological and educational sciences and in the pooling of clinical trial results. Sources of bias are not controlled by the method a good metaanalysis of badly designed studies will still result in bad statistics. Epidemiological and other observational studies typically highlight associations between exposures and outcomes, rather than causation. Neighbourhood socioeconomic status and overweightobesity. The systematic literature search was conducted by two investigators l. Relevant studies were identified by pubmed 1966 to march 2015 and embase 1974 to march 2015 database search through march 2015. A metaanalysis method was conducted to estimate relative risk combining all relative data. Bradford hill criteria 7 contend that an entire body of evidence is needed before determining if. The number of nonreference exposure levels nk for the kth study might varies among the s studies. Many commentators have cautioned that metaanalysis may not yet be ready for widespread use, especially for observational studies. Meta analysis of observational studies in epidemiology a proposal for reporting donna f.
Association between htlv1 infection and adverse health. To better understand the association, we conducted a metaanalysis of epidemiological studies. Impact of blinding on estimated treatment effects in. A method for metaanalysis of epidemiological studies. Metaanalysis of epidemiological doseresponse studies. However the increasing use of meta analysis in observational studies should encourage the more formal reporting of aetiological studies, to facilitate thecombiningof such results. The metaanalysis of all studies yielded a pooled or, adjusted for. Thus, this study was done to synthesise the existing evidence on the association of nses with overweight, obesity and body mass. This article presents a stepwise approach for conducting a metaanalysis of epidemiological studies based on proposed guidelines. Prevalence and epidemiological characteristics of congenital. The studies included in this metaanalysis were required to meet all the following criteria. To better understand the association, we conducted a meta analysis of epidemiological studies. Pubmed and embase were searched through april 2017. The historical roots of meta analysis can be traced back to 17th century studies of astronomy, while a paper published in 1904 by the statistician karl pearson in the british medical journal which collated data from several studies of typhoid inoculation is seen as the first time a meta analytic approach was used to aggregate the outcomes of multiple clinical studies.
However the increasing use of metaanalysis in observational studies should encourage the more formal reporting of aetiological studies, to facilitate thecombiningof such results. This systematic method is recommended for practitioners evaluating. Objective low neighbourhood socioeconomic status nses has been linked to a higher risk of overweightobesity, irrespective of the individuals own socioeconomic status. In general, we did not find any association between milkdairy products or galactose metabolism and ovarian cancer risk in this metaanalysis. The use of metaanalyses in order to synthesise the evidence from epidemiological studies has become more and more popular recently. Indeed the direct comparison of results from meta analyses. The latter included one incidence study, the remainder were prevalence studies. Does talking on a cell phone, with a passenger, or dialing. Objectives the authors performed a metaanalysis of casecontrol and cohort studies to clarify the possible relationship between exposure to pesticides and childhood cancers. No association between fiber intake and prostate cancer risk. Qin lq, xu jy, wang py, hoshi k 2006 soyfood intake in the prevention of breast cancer risk in women. Abstractthe objective was to document the operational definitions applied in epidemiological studies of chronic pain and to examine whether pain definitions and other methodological factors are systematically related to prevalence estimates. Sep 25, 2014 emerging background of meta epidemiology. In particular, it has been used extensively within the medical sciences 2.
670 893 1346 885 1330 842 925 702 1036 923 1023 878 511 1472 351 102 106 730 1116 1524 187 1231 271 1181 362 643 716 521 1298 70 959 93 716 635 1341